🔌 Help keep GC online

Amor Fati: Episode 10 - As It Was Meant to Be

Share
Amor Fati: Episode 10 - As It Was Meant to Be
Photo by Aron Visuals / Unsplash

by Elyse Harrison
Previous episodes
Clara hesitated at first, but then finally sighed, ‘Sure.’ She adjusted her jacket around her shoulders and stepped outside, pulling the front door shut behind her.

For a while they walked in silence, drifting aimlessly through the quiet streets. Neither seemed eager to be the first to speak. Eventually, James broke.

‘I heard about your mum.’ His voice was careful. ‘I thought about coming to the funeral, but I figured it was better if I stayed away.’ He glanced at her. ‘What happened?’

Clara kept walking. For several moments, she said nothing. ‘She suffered for years,’ she replied finally. ‘But in the end, I think she died of a broken heart.’

James's brow furrowed.

Clara folded her arms. ‘When you lose someone you love enough, a part of you never really recovers.’ The words came out sharper than she intended. She wasn't entirely sure whether she was talking about her mother or herself.

James seemed to understand, nevertheless. ‘I deserved that.’

Clara didn't answer. The silence stretched between them again.

‘Clara,’ James said quietly. ‘I'm sorry.’

She continued walking.

‘That night. The dance. The tree.’

His words caused her stomach to tighten.

‘When I left you there and got in the car, I had time to think. Too much time.’ He laughed bitterly. ‘I started thinking about the future. About everything we'd promised each other. Running away. Getting married. Building a life together.’

 Clara stared ahead. ‘You proposed to me, James.’

‘I know.’

‘And then you vanished.’

His shoulders sagged. ‘I was scared.’

The admission was so simple that it almost made her angry.

‘You disappeared because you were scared?’

‘I thought I was doing the right thing.’

Clara stopped walking. ‘The right thing for who?’

James opened his mouth but couldn't answer.

‘I loved you,’ Clara said. ‘You didn't even give me the chance to decide for myself.’ The hurt she'd spent thirteen years burying threatened to surface.

James looked down. ‘I thought I wasn't enough for you.’

‘That wasn't your decision to make.’

‘I know that now.’

They resumed walking. Minutes later they reached the park. The tree. Both of them recognised it immediately.

James slowed. Clara's chest tightened.

Beneath its sprawling branches was the place where they'd made impossible promises as eighteen-year-olds. The place where James had slipped a ring onto her finger and promised her forever.

And the place where, days later, Clara had returned alone.

She remembered standing there with tears streaming down her face, digging into the soft earth with trembling hands. Burying the ring, and along with it, her future. Or at least the future she'd dared to imagine.

James stared at the tree. ‘I've thought about that night more times than I can count.’

Clara averted her gaze. ‘After you left, I buried the ring here.’

James looked at her sharply. ‘You what?’

‘I couldn't look at it anymore.’

The confession seemed to strike him harder than anything else she'd said. His face fell. ‘I didn't know.’

‘Of course you didn't know.’

James swallowed. ‘Clara, if I could go back–’

‘But you can't.’

He nodded. ‘No.’

A long silence followed.

Finally, Clara spoke. ‘I agree with you about one thing.’

James looked up.

‘We were eighteen. Getting married and running away together was impulsive and ridiculous.’

To her surprise, he laughed softly. ‘It really was.’

‘But my heart still broke when you didn't show up.’

The smile vanished.

‘It took me years to recover from that.’ She paused. ‘But I did recover.’ For the first time all evening, Clara felt certain of her words. ‘I wouldn't change what happened.’

James frowned. ‘You wouldn't?’

‘No.’

She met his gaze. ‘Because every choice we make shapes who we become. Maybe things could have turned out differently. Maybe they could have turned out better.’ She shrugged. ‘But I like who I am. Even if getting here hurt.’

James studied her for a long moment.

As they walked back towards her house, neither spoke again. When they reached her porch, Clara unlocked the front door. Part of her wanted to step inside and never open it again. Trust wasn't rebuilt in an evening. Thirteen years of silence didn't disappear because of an apology.

She crossed the threshold. Behind her, James finally spoke. ‘You know,’ he said quietly, ‘I never stopped loving you, Clara.’

She closed her eyes. The words she'd spent years imagining. The words that changed nothing and everything.

Clara glanced back over her shoulder. ‘Me too.’ Then she stepped inside and softly closed the door.


As Clara stood behind the door, her back pressed against the smooth timber, she heard something crackle beneath her foot.

An envelope lay on the floor. Across the front, written in unmistakable handwriting, was her name.

Clara.

With trembling fingers, she picked it up and carefully withdrew the card inside. It was from her mother. The note contained the now familiar phrase:

Amor Fati.

Then beneath it, its meaning: To love one's fate.

Clara stared at the words as tears welled in her eyes. For years she had fought against loss and grief. Against the things life had taken from her. Her father. Her mother. James. Yet somehow those same losses had shaped the person she had become.

For a moment, everything was still. Then came a knock at the door.

Clara froze. For years, knocks on doors had carried the weight of endings. But standing there with her mother's note clutched in her hand, Clara realised something.

Not every knock brought sorrow. Some brought possibility and second chances. A small smile tugged at the corner of her mouth.

She opened the door.

James stood on the porch.

Clara noticed the dirt first. It covered his hands and streaked the knees of his jeans. His chest rose and fell rapidly, as though he had run all the way there. Then she saw what he held.

A ring. The ring.

Clara stared at it in disbelief. 'You dug it up?' she whispered.

James glanced down at the ring resting in his palm and gave a small, nervous laugh. 'You really weren't kidding when you said you buried it.'

For a moment neither of them spoke.

The years between them seemed to dissolve. The hurt, the regret, and the missed opportunities. All of it had led them here.

James stepped forward. Then, slowly, he lowered himself onto one knee. His classic smile returned.

The smile Clara had fallen in love with all those years ago. The smile she suspected she had never truly stopped loving.

Holding the ring out towards her, he met her gaze. ‘Clara,’ he said softly, ‘thirteen years ago I let fear decide my future.’ His voice trembled. ‘I don't want to make that mistake again.’

Clara felt tears spill down her cheeks.

‘Will you marry me?’

For a heartbeat the world stood still.

And for the first time in a very long time, Clara found herself loving her fate.

THE END


About the Author: Elyse Harrison

Picture: Julia Pratt, Jubkate Art (@jub.kate)

Elyse Harrison is an environmental professional and writer based in Geelong. Her writing explores the connections between people, animals, history and the natural world, often weaving together themes of hope, grief, belonging, love, and environmental stewardship. Drawing inspiration from nature, philosophy, and the enduring relationships between humans and animals, she writes poetry and fiction that seeks to find meaning in the fleeting moments that shape our lives.

https://www.facebook.com/ElyseHarrisonWriter/